Skip to content
Birthday Basket

Return Gift Ideas for Kids' Birthday Parties, by Age Group

Return gift ideas for kids birthday parties, sorted by age group, with advice on how many to buy, what to avoid and how to present them.

By Birthday BasketPublished 4 min read

Rows of colourful patterned gift bags ready to hand out to guests
In this guide
  1. Before you choose: three questions
  2. Return gift ideas for kids birthday parties: ages 1–3
  3. Ages 4–6
  4. Ages 7–9
  5. Ages 10–12
  6. Ideas that suit any age
  7. Presentation
  8. How many to buy
  9. What to avoid
  10. When to hand them out
  11. Themed return gifts
  12. More sustainable choices
  13. Simple, useful and age-appropriate

Good return gift ideas for kids birthday parties share three qualities: the child will use the gift, the parent will not resent it, and it suits the age of the guest. A return gift is a thank-you, not a competition, and the ones that are remembered are usually the simple, useful ones.

This guide sorts ideas by age group and covers the practical questions: how many, how to wrap them and what to steer clear of.

Before you choose: three questions

How many guests, and how old? Count the invited children, then note the youngest and oldest. If the range is wide, plan two versions of the gift.

What is the budget per gift? Decide a figure per child and multiply by the number of guests plus spares. It is easier to choose within a limit than to choose first and count later.

Is there a theme? A gift that connects to the party theme feels thoughtful with no extra cost. See kids' birthday party themes.

Return gift ideas for kids birthday parties: ages 1–3

Safety comes first. Avoid anything with small parts, and remember that the parent is really the recipient.

  • Board books
  • Chunky crayons
  • Bath toys
  • Soft balls
  • Stacking cups
  • Bibs or small towels

Many toys are labelled for age for this reason. Check the label, and see baby-safe birthday decorations for more on small-part hazards.

Ages 4–6

Children this age love to make and to pretend.

  • Colouring books with crayons
  • Sticker sheets and activity pads
  • Play dough
  • Bubbles
  • Small puzzles
  • Water bottles or lunch boxes
  • Story books
  • Seed kits with a small pot

Ages 7–9

Now they want something to do or to collect.

  • Craft kits
  • Stationery sets: pencils, erasers, sharpeners, a pouch
  • Card games
  • Sketch pads with colour pencils
  • Building or model kits
  • Jump ropes
  • Notebooks or diaries

Ages 10–12

Tweens value things that feel grown-up.

  • Journals and gel pens
  • Board or card games
  • Puzzle cubes
  • Reusable bottles or mugs
  • Keychains and bag charms
  • Books
  • Art supplies

Ideas that suit any age

GiftWhy it works
BooksAlways used; easy to match to age
StationeryUseful for school, hard to get wrong
Plants or seed kitsMemorable, and lasts well beyond the party
Water bottlesPractical and long-lasting
Art suppliesEncourages making rather than accumulating

Presentation

A modest gift in good packaging feels generous.

  • Use bags or boxes in the party colours.
  • Add a tag with each child's name. It prevents arguments and makes the gift personal.
  • Tie on a thank-you note from the birthday child, in their own handwriting if they can write.
  • Display the gifts on a table near the door as part of the decoration.
Themed favour boxes on a stand beside a cluster of metallic balloons
Favour boxes in the party colours, displayed near the door as part of the decoration.

How many to buy

Buy one for each invited child, plus spares.

  • Add three or four extra for siblings who come along.
  • If you are doing two age versions, add a spare to each.
  • Keep leftovers. They are useful for the next party or as small gifts later.

It is far better to have five left over than to be one short with a child waiting.

What to avoid

  • Small parts for under-threes. A choking risk; RoSPA's toy safety guidance explains why age labels matter.
  • Whistles and noisy toys. Parents will not thank you.
  • Slime and anything that stains. Not everyone wants it in the car.
  • Large amounts of sweets. Some families restrict sugar, and allergies are common.
  • Anything fragile. It will be broken before they reach home.
  • Food with common allergens unless you have checked with parents.

When to hand them out

At the end, at the door, as each family leaves. Handing gifts out earlier means they get lost, broken or fought over during the party. Put one adult in charge, with the list of names.

If the birthday child is old enough, let them hand each gift over and say thank you. It turns the moment into a small lesson in gratitude.

Themed return gifts

  • Jungle or animals: animal figures, seed kits
  • Space: glow-in-the-dark stars, a notebook
  • Art party: a sketch pad and pencils
  • Sports: a ball or a jump rope
  • Under the sea: bath toys, bubbles
  • Superheroes: a cape or mask

More sustainable choices

If you want to reduce waste, choose gifts that are used up or kept: plants, books, art supplies, reusable bottles. Use paper bags rather than plastic, and skip the filler. A single well-chosen item beats a bag of small plastic toys.

Simple, useful and age-appropriate

The return gift ideas for kids birthday parties that work are rarely the most expensive. Choose by age, buy a few spares, wrap them in the party colours and hand them out at the door.

Tell Birthday Basket the age range and the number of guests, and ask what return gifts and favours are in the shop. For the rest of the party, see the birthday party planning checklist.

Cover photo by Muhammad Shamaoon Malik on Pexels.

This guide is part of our Kids & First Birthdays series. For the full picture, start with First Birthday Decoration Ideas: A Calm, Photo-Ready Guide.

From the shop

Tableware

Party tableware for birthdays and celebrations at home.

View category

Keep reading

Tell us what you’re planning.

Send the date, the colours and a rough guest count on WhatsApp, and ask what’s in the shop right now.